Rumplestiltskin’s Lawyer Sums Up

No one can contest that a contract existed

Between my client and the respondent;

That much is beyond debate—nor did my client coerce

This miller’s-daughter-who-would be queen,

Unless one would argue that providing her the means to obtain

All that she truly desired somehow equates to coercion.

As for my learned colleague’s claim that the agreement is void

Due to the imposition of usurious terms by my client,

May I remind you that at no point did the respondent

In this case decline to accept this quid pro quo;

Indeed, she happily re-negotiated the terms

Of the very pact she now seeks to void!

 

“Ah,” opposing counsel claims, “Our client fulfilled

The terms of the agreement in accordance with the law.”

I must say, I find my distinguished friend’s definition

Of fulfillment rather odd—through the use of illegal trespass

And surveillance methods of dubious legitimacy,

His client gained such information as was required

To exercise the out-clause of this agreement,

So if one accepts the use of industrial espionage as a valid means

Of satisfying a contractual obligation, I suppose the argument holds water.

Whether legal precedent supports such an argument

Is, at best, highly uncertain.

 

Again, members of the jury, I know full well where your sympathies lie.

All along, opposing counsel has implied we should celebrate her pluckiness,

Her cunning and initiative, her stunning trip

From rags to riches. My friends, I would argue this:

There is, indeed, a moral to every story.

Are our obligations and promises no more, at the end of the day,

Than mere the interview portions of a beauty pageant,

Where a winning smile or long blonde hair

Serve as just cause to blithely disregard those oaths?

Are our most sacred vows less binding on those

That nature has made the mirror a friend to

Than those of us who are unattractive and underloved?

Ladies and gentlemen, it is up to you to write

The final chapter of our fable. I thank you.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s